With 34 communities, thousands of caregivers and frequent CMS audits, Benedictine has never failed a PBJ audit. Here's the operating model behind that record.
When the Audit Request Lands
Every skilled nursing leader knows the moment. A request arrives from CMS asking you to back up the staffing hours you reported through Payroll-Based Journal (PBJ). Every shift, every nurse, every agency hour has to match.
For many skilled nursing organizations, that request sets off a scramble. Someone pulls timecards from separate systems, reconciles agency invoices by hand and chases team members about missing punches, all against a deadline.
At Benedictine, it sets off a routine. The organization runs 34 communities across the full continuum of care, with 5,000 to 6,000 employees, most of them direct care staff. It is audited often and in detail. And it has never failed a PBJ audit.
That record didn't come from working harder at audit time. It came from standardizing processes, workforce data and workflows into one Smartlinx platform. Here’s how Benedictine did it.
The Challenge: Multiple Communities Was Making Compliance Harder
Growth brings strength, and it brings complexity. Benedictine's communities had been operating independently for a while, each with its own way of handling staffing and time. With 34 communities, it started to create friction:
• Disconnected processes. Scheduling, time tracking and compliance lived in separate places.
• Heavy PBJ workload. Quarterly reporting and audit preparation consumed a lot of time becoming an administrative burden.
• Limited visibility. Leadership had a hard time seeing overtime, labor trends and staffing alignment across the organization.
• A balancing act. Corporate needed consistency, while local teams needed the freedom to run their own buildings.
The Solution: One Connected Platform from Staffing to PBJ
Benedictine implemented Smartlinx to bring its workforce operations into a single system, with one standardized approach across every community. Instead of passing data between tools, teams now manage the full workforce lifecycle in one place:
It starts with a budget that sets labor targets for each community. Ideal schedules tie staffing plans to census and budget, so the schedule reflects what residents need and what the community can sustain. Schedulers fill daily shifts against that plan, and time and attendance captures actual hours as caregivers work them. PBJ submissions then draw on that same data, validated before it goes out.
This connection is what changes compliance. When planned staffing, actual hours and payroll data live in the same system, PBJ data stops being a quarterly reconstruction project. It becomes a byproduct of everyday work and simple reporting.
The details that matter most to auditors are built in. Validation catches errors before submission. Contractor and agency hours are tracked with the same precision as employee hours, and PBJ reports are built right in. And because every community follows the same process, the data means the same thing everywhere.
The result: a reporting process that would be unmanageable by hand now takes minutes.
Corporate Oversight with Individual Community Control
Standardizing on the Smartlinx platform didn't mean taking decisions away from the people closest to residents. Benedictine split the work deliberately.
Each community builds and manages its own schedules and runs its day-to-day operations. Administrators and schedulers still make the calls they're best placed to make, like covering a callout or adjusting for a census change.
Corporate teams provide governance, training and oversight. They set the standards, support every site in using them and see workforce data across all 34 communities in one view.
That split is what lets the model scale. Consistency comes from shared processes and shared data, not from central control of every shift.
Zero Failed Audits and Time Back for Leaders
This headline says it all: across years of frequent, detailed CMS audits, Benedictine has never failed a PBJ audit.
"When it comes to PBJ and compliance, there really isn't another solution that compares. We're managing audits constantly, and we've never failed one — because we trust the data, and we know the Smartlinx system is getting every detail right."
— Dodee Horgen, Application Specialist, Time & Attendance, Benedictine
The gains go beyond audits:
• Near-perfect audit accuracy, with error rates consistently well below industry thresholds.
• Zero PBJ audit failures across years of CMS audits, despite frequent and detailed reviews.
• PBJ Reporting in minutes. PBJ preparation went from a manual, high-risk process to an automated workflow.
• Clear view of labor. Automated overtime reporting and trend monitoring show leaders where hours are going before payroll closes.
• Better staffing alignment. Ideal schedules tied to census and budget keep staffing matched to resident needs.
The biggest change may be the one that's hardest to measure. Hours that once went to reconciling timecards now go to supporting caregivers and the residents they serve.
What Other Multi-Community Operators Can Take From This
Benedictine's approach holds lessons for any organization managing staffing across several communities:
1. Make PBJ accuracy an outcome, not a task. When hours are captured correctly every day, the quarterly report takes care of itself.
2. Centralize in one system and give local team autonomy. Give corporate teams shared processes and visibility and let communities own their daily staffing.
3. Tie schedules to census and budget. Ideal schedules make overtime and staffing gaps visible before they show up on payroll.
From Reactive to Ready
For Benedictine, an audit request is no longer a fire drill. It's a normal part of the week, handled with data the team already trusts.
By moving to one connected workforce platform, Benedictine traded fragmented, reactive processes to proactive centralized workforce control. The result is compliance it can count on, efficiency at every location and a foundation that scales as the organization grows.
Read the full Benedictine customer success story and see how Smartlinx handles PBJ reporting.
See the Smartlinx platform in action, request a demo today.





















